Download these notes here: https://humble-sidecar-837.notion.site/The-Church-Today-From-Fosdick-to-Osteen-26eb35a87d638099b556ecb635fe3b6f?source=copy_link
I. Setting the Stage: Why This Matters
The church has drifted from its moorings, trading doctrinal clarity for cultural relevance.
Evangelicalism once anchored in Scripture is now shallow, therapeutic, and compromised.
Our task: trace the road that got us here, recognize the errors, and recover the biblical role of the church.
II. The Chautauqua Movement: Preparing the Soil
Blurring faith and entertainment – preaching as performance, Bible as moralism.
Religion as politics – Progressive Era causes (temperance, suffrage, reform) tied to Scripture.
Spectacle-driven religion – emotional highs without doctrinal depth.
Key figure: William Jennings Bryan – embodied the fusion of faith, politics, and entertainment.
Result – a Christianity more horizontal than vertical, man-centered rather than God-centered.
III. Harry Emerson Fosdick (1920s–1940s): The Catalyst of Progressive Christianity
1922 sermon: “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?” – rejected virgin birth, inerrancy, substitutionary atonement.
Shift – from doctrinal orthodoxy to cultural accommodation.
Platform: Riverside Church – Rockefeller-funded center for liberal theology.
Core themes – reason and experience over Scripture, social reform over salvation.
Legacy – religion redefined as progress, paving the way for self-help Christianity.
IV. Norman Vincent Peale (1940s–1950s): The Power of Positive Thinking
Pragmatic religion – sermons as therapy, not exegesis.
Self-help Christianity – success, optimism, visualization of goals.
Positive Thinking (1952) – faith reduced to mantras, Scripture stripped of context.
Impact – theology thinned to psychology; focus on self, not God.
Link to Fosdick – same man-centered religion, different packaging.
V. Robert Schuller (1960s–1980s): Self-Esteem Theology
Drive-in church to Crystal Cathedral – spectacle and accessibility.
Hour of Power – Christianity as television production.
Core error – redefinition of sin as lack of self-esteem.
Focus – self-worth, not salvation; affirmation, not atonement.
Legacy – megachurch model, entertainment-driven religion, gospel as product.
VI. Joel Osteen (1990s–Present): The Prosperity Gospel Standard
Lakewood Church – America’s largest megachurch.
Message – “Your Best Life Now”; health, wealth, and positivity.
Core elements – material wealth as faith, avoidance of doctrine, media mastery.
Result – perfected cultural accommodation, exported globally.
Culmination – evangelicalism indistinguishable from self-help aisle.
VII. Common Threads in the Drift
1. Therapeutic emphasis – religion as emotional uplift.
2. De-emphasis of doctrine – shallow, practical “life lessons.”
3. Cultural relevance – bending faith to fit the age.
4. Mass appeal – pursuit of crowds, marketing over truth.
5. Optimism and prosperity – Christianity rebranded as success and progress.
6. Aesthetics and production – spectacle over substance.
VIII. Where Evangelicalism Is Today
A hybrid of liberalism, social gospel, self-help, prosperity, and showmanship.
A therapeutic message that soothes but does not last.
A church that mirrors culture instead of confronting it.
IX. Recovering the Church’s Mission
Reject cultural accommodation; return to the inerrant Word.
Stand as the “pillar and ground of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15).
Reclaim literal, rightly-divided preaching and teaching of Scripture.
Call Christians back to the church as an assembly for Biblical learning—not a show, not therapy, not self-help.
Supplemental: Key Figures in the Drift
Harry Emerson Fosdick (1878–1969)
Strengths: A brilliant communicator with sharp intellect and broad cultural awareness. Fosdick made liberal theology sound respectable from the pulpit, not just the academy.
Reach: His 1922 sermon “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?” shook the American church, putting modernism in the headlines.
Platform: First Presbyterian, then Riverside Church—built by Rockefeller Jr. specifically for his ministry—gave him the loudest megaphone of his era.
Appeal: To the educated classes, he embodied sophistication; to the broader public, he offered a Christianity that kept pace with science, culture, and progress.
Norman Vincent Peale (1898–1993)
Strengths: A natural salesman with a positive, upbeat demeanor who blended psychology and religion seamlessly.
Reach: As pastor of Marble Collegiate Church in New York City, his weekly messages went out over radio and television long before most pastors thought about media.
Platform: His book The Power of Positive Thinking (1952) sold millions, shaping not just Christians but American business culture.
Appeal: He gave people a sense that faith could solve anxiety, improve self-confidence, and guarantee success—messages that connected deeply in post-war America.
Robert Schuller (1926–2015)
Strengths: A showman with uncanny instinct for presentation, production, and accessibility. Schuller could package anything in a way people wanted to consume.
Reach: His Hour of Power television broadcast at its peak reached 20 million viewers in 180 countries.
Platform: The Crystal Cathedral, a $55 million glass-and-steel spectacle, became the visual icon of American Christianity for decades.
Appeal: He told people that their biggest problem wasn’t sin but poor self-esteem—something they wanted to believe. His positivity drew massive audiences and celebrity endorsements.
Joel Osteen (1963– )
Strengths: A polished speaker with an unmatched gift for warmth, optimism, and universal appeal. His smile was his strongest asset, and he leaned into it.
Reach: Pastor of Lakewood Church in Houston, now the largest church in America, with 40,000+ in weekly attendance and millions watching worldwide.
Platform: His books (Your Best Life Now, etc.) became international bestsellers, translated into dozens of languages.
Appeal: He avoids controversy and doctrine altogether, offering a message of prosperity, blessing, and happiness that fits hand-in-glove with modern consumer culture.
